Environment Agency
Hutton, 62, of Short Cross Road, Mount Hawke, Truro, pleaded guilty at Truro Crown Court in March 2020 to 2 charges of running the business, Skip It, without an environmental permit.
One charge related to deposit and storage of controlled waste on land at Mawla, Porthtowan and the other to the deposit and storage of controlled waste, on land adjacent to a Western Power Distribution sub-station, at Penwinnick Road, near St Agnes.
The Environment Agency went back to the court with a Proceeds of Crime application against Hutton and was awarded 198,000 on 28 October 2022. Hutton was also sentenced for the offences, fined a total of 10,000 and ordered to pay 29,000 in costs.
Hutton has a maximum of 6 months to pay up or face 18 months in prison if he fails to pay the 198,000 and 3 months imprisonment if he fails to pay the fines and costs.
Both sites being used for the business could have led to environmental harm, particularly the one close to an electricity sub-station, Judge Carr was told. The Mawla site had a bund erected around it to shield it from view by the public. Hutton had continued to operate the sites after being interviewed under caution by Environment Agency officers.
The court heard Hutton had a previous conviction for a similar offence from 2001. The judge told him: Regulations are there for a reason. You gained a competitive advantage over others by not being licenced or permitted. You were given warnings and chances but failed to comply.
Stephen Clark of the Environment Agency said:
Craig Hutton deliberately operated the business without the required permits, threatening the environment and earning thousands of pounds from customers.
The Environment Agency will vigorously pursue those who flout the law in this way, and who undermine legitimate businesses.
Background
Craig Hutton was charged with:
Between 22 November 2018 and 22 February 2019 Craig Hutton [and Stuart Hutton] operated a Regulated Facility, namely a waste operation including the deposit and storage of controlled waste, on land close to Mount Pleasant Eco Park, Mawla, Porthtowan, Cornwall, in respect of which no environmental permit was in force. Contrary to regulations 38(1)(a) and 12(1)(a) of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016.
Between 5 December 2018 and 7 November 2019 Craig Hutton, operated a Regulated Facility, namely a waste operation including the deposit and storage of controlled waste, on land adjacent to Western Power Distribution sub-station, Penwinnick Road, near St Agnes, Cornwall, in respect of which no environmental permit was in force. Contrary to regulations 38(1)(a) and 12(1)(a) of the Environmental Permittin